The Difference Between Pain and Suffering

From Tantra Is Not What You Think, by Daniel Penrose

Pain is the raw sensation, an ache or hurt that's real and often unavoidable. Suffering is the story you wrap around it: this shouldn't be happening, it'll never end. Pain is felt; suffering is built, and the built part can be set down.

In short

Two things wearing one coat

When something hurts, it feels like one solid block of misery. Look closely, though, and it splits into two. There is the pain itself, a sensation, located somewhere, rising and easing. And there is the suffering, the words wrapped around it: this is unbearable, it'll never lift, what's wrong with me.

The first is honest and survivable. The second is made of language, and it is usually the part that flattens you. Pain is a sensation; suffering is the story about the sensation. Telling them apart is the beginning of relief.

Where does it actually hurt?

The story sells you “total, endless, unbearable.” The body tells a truer tale. So when a hard feeling hits, drop out of the words and into the body, and go looking for the actual sensation. Where is it? A weight in the chest, a hollow in the gut, a tightness in the throat?

You will almost always find it is smaller than the story swore — it has edges where the story said it was endless, and it moves where the story said it was permanent. It still hurts. But it becomes something you can be with rather than something you must flee.

Grief is meant to be felt

One careful thing: dropping the suffering is not the same as dropping the pain. Some pain is meant to be felt all the way through. Grief especially, the ache of losing someone is not a malfunction to reason away; the feeling is the love, still moving. Letting go of suffering means dropping the extra layer (“I shouldn't still feel this”), so the honest grief has room to do its slow, real work without that crushing weight on top.

A short practice

If what you're carrying is heavier than everyday weight, if it doesn't lift, or frightens you, that is information, not weakness; please let a doctor or professional help you carry it. The free 7-day guide practises this gently, and the full teaching is in the book Tantra Is Not What You Think.

Common questions

What is the difference between pain and suffering?

Pain is the raw, physical-or-emotional sensation, real and often unavoidable. Suffering is the mental story layered on top: “this shouldn't be happening, it'll never end.” Pain is felt; suffering is constructed, and the constructed part can be loosened.

Can you have pain without suffering?

Yes, that's the whole point. When you feel the bare sensation without wrapping it in resistance and catastrophe, the pain remains but the extra, self-made layer falls away. The hurt becomes something you can be with rather than flee.

Does this mean I shouldn't feel sad or grieve?

Not at all. Some pain, especially grief, is meant to be felt fully, the feeling is love still moving. You drop only the second story (“I shouldn't still feel this”) so the honest feeling has room to move through you.

How do I tell the story apart from the real feeling?

Drop out of the words and into the body. Ask where the feeling actually lives, chest, gut, throat, and find its edges. The sensation is usually smaller and more movable than the story claimed. Whatever is left in words is the suffering.

Want the whole thing, gently?

This is one idea from Tantra Is Not What You Think, the calm, modern guide to letting everything be. Start with the free 7-day letting-go guide, or read the book.

Get the free 7-day guide Read the book